 |
| 16 Shows Like This Is Poly You Need to Watch Next If You’re Hooked on WE tv’s Most Talked-About Reality Series. (Credits: WE tv) |
This Is Poly has quickly become one of those reality shows that leaves viewers staring at the screen thinking, “Well, that was certainly a conversation starter.” By following five very different polycules as they navigate commitment, family life, communication challenges and everyday relationship chaos, the WE tv series offers a rare look at people building connections outside traditional relationship structures. Unsurprisingly, plenty of viewers finished the first episodes wanting more shows with similar themes, complicated dynamics and enough emotional twists to make group chats explode.
What makes This Is Poly stand out is that it isn't just about romance. It is about trust, family, jealousy, communication and the occasional moment where everyone involved seems one awkward conversation away from needing a very long holiday. If you're searching for reality series and documentaries that explore unconventional relationships, modern dating, family dynamics or alternative lifestyles, these 16 shows should be next on your watchlist.
Shows Like This Is Poly
1. Seeking Sister Wife
If The Yahwehs caught your attention, then Seeking Sister Wife is probably your next stop. The reality series follows families exploring plural marriages and the challenges that come with adding new partners into existing relationships.
Much like This Is Poly, it dives into communication breakdowns, emotional adjustments and family politics. The difference is that the stakes somehow feel even higher when multiple households are involved.
2. Polyamory: Married & Dating
Often considered one of the closest matches to This Is Poly, this series follows several polyamorous families as they balance multiple romantic relationships.
The show explores jealousy, scheduling conflicts, emotional boundaries and relationship growth. Think of it as a spiritual predecessor that walked so This Is Poly could run.
3. Couples Therapy
While not focused specifically on polyamory, Couples Therapy examines real relationships through professional counselling sessions.
Viewers who enjoy watching people work through communication struggles, trust issues and emotional conflicts will find plenty of familiar themes here. Sometimes the most dramatic scene is simply two people sitting on a sofa trying not to interrupt each other.
4. Love Without Limits
This reality series follows people involved in non-traditional relationship structures and explores how they navigate modern love. Like This Is Poly, it challenges assumptions about what relationships should look like while highlighting the practical realities behind them.
5. Married at First Sight
At first glance, the premise may seem very different. However, both shows examine how people create relationships under unusual circumstances. Fans who enjoy emotional growth, awkward conversations and unexpected relationship developments will likely appreciate the similarities.
6. Love Is Blind
Few reality shows generate as much discussion as Love Is Blind. While the format focuses on emotional connections before physical attraction, it shares This Is Poly's fascination with communication, trust and defining modern relationships. It also proves that people can make life-changing decisions surprisingly quickly when cameras are involved.
7. The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives
This breakout reality series explores friendships, relationships and family life within a unique social circle. Viewers drawn to the personal stories and community dynamics of This Is Poly may find this equally fascinating, especially as tensions frequently simmer beneath the surface.
8. Extreme Love
This documentary-style series showcases unconventional relationships from around the world. The show examines how people create meaningful connections despite societal expectations, making it a natural recommendation for anyone interested in alternative lifestyles and relationship models.
9. Sister Wives
One of reality television's most recognisable relationship-focused programmes, Sister Wives follows a large plural family as they manage daily life, parenting and interpersonal tensions. Fans of The Yahweh Family's complex household structure will likely find plenty to analyse here.
10. Temptation Island
Relationship tests, emotional uncertainty and difficult conversations are all central ingredients in Temptation Island. While the format differs from This Is Poly, both series explore how relationships respond under pressure and what happens when trust is challenged.
11. Love After Lockup
Viewers may already recognise Kami and Trent from this WE tv hit. The series follows couples attempting to build relationships after one partner leaves prison. Like This Is Poly, it focuses on real people facing real complications, often with unpredictable outcomes.
12. Seeking Brother Husband
This companion series flips traditional expectations by following women seeking multiple male partners. The show explores many of the same themes found in This Is Poly, including communication, boundaries, family acceptance and relationship logistics.
13. Dating Around
For viewers who enjoy observing relationship chemistry develop from scratch, Dating Around offers a fascinating look at modern dating. While less dramatic than some reality shows, it provides honest insights into compatibility and connection.
14. Indian Matchmaking
This globally popular reality series follows singles navigating matchmaking, family expectations and cultural traditions. Although the relationship structure differs significantly, the programme shares an interest in how people define partnership and commitment.
15. Love on the Spectrum
One of the most heartfelt dating series of recent years, Love on the Spectrum focuses on authentic human connections and relationship journeys. Fans who appreciate the emotional honesty found in This Is Poly may find this particularly rewarding.
16. Open House: The Great Sex Experiment
This British reality series follows committed couples exploring ways to strengthen their relationships through unconventional experiences. While the premise can be provocative, the core themes of communication, trust and relationship boundaries closely mirror many of the conversations happening throughout This Is Poly.
The reaction to This Is Poly has been predictably varied online. Some viewers praise the series for presenting relationship structures that rarely receive mainstream television attention.
Others are fascinated by the family dynamics, particularly the enormous household featured by The Yahwehs. Meanwhile, plenty of social media users admit they originally tuned in out of curiosity but stayed for the surprisingly emotional conversations and interpersonal drama.
There are also viewers who appreciate that the show spends as much time discussing communication, commitment and family life as it does relationship labels.
On the other hand, some audiences remain sceptical about whether certain polycules can successfully manage such complex dynamics long term. In reality television terms, that difference of opinion is probably exactly what producers were hoping for.
Whether you watch This Is Poly for the relationship discussions, the family stories, the unexpected twists or simply to see what happens next, these 16 shows offer plenty of similar themes and unforgettable moments.
Have you watched any of them already? Which series do you think comes closest to capturing the same energy as This Is Poly? Let us know your favourites and which show deserves a place on every reality TV fan's watchlist.