 |
| Is Carr Straight or Queer in All’s Fair? Season 2 Finally Drops a Major Hint. |
Carr's complicated relationship with Liberty Ronson might be heading in a rather unexpected direction in All’s Fair Season 2. While Liberty has finally embraced her sexuality and started a new relationship with Jamie, Carr is beginning to question something she has apparently kept to herself for years: whether she might also be attracted to women.
Her unexpected confession during a terrifying flight changes the way viewers see the usually sharp-tongued lawyer, raising an interesting question about her sexuality and whether there could be more between her and Liberty than their familiar professional rivalry.
Liberty's journey towards self-acceptance has been one of the more personal developments in the second season. After nearly marrying the wrong person in the previous season, she decides that honesty should come first, particularly when it comes to her romantic life. This leads her to acknowledge a part of herself that she has suppressed for years and publicly come out as a lesbian. Her closest friends respond with warmth and support, making it clear that they are firmly behind her.
The reaction is considerably less friendly when it comes to Carr. At the Scorpio Ball, where Liberty introduces her girlfriend Jamie, Carr wastes little time making her feelings known through a series of cutting remarks. However, her attitude seems less connected to Liberty's sexuality and more to their long-running professional competition. After all, these two have never exactly been known for exchanging compliments over a cup of coffee.
Still, Carr's behaviour begins to look rather different following the events of Season 2, Episode 2. During a disastrous flight involving the firm's lawyers, she reveals something that puts her own sexuality under the spotlight.
The journey is supposed to honour Dina's late husband, Doug, by taking his ashes to his family tomb. Dina wants her mentees, including Carr, to accompany her, so the group boards her private jet. Unfortunately, Carr is already a nervous flyer, and this trip quickly becomes the sort of experience that makes even the most experienced traveller reconsider their holiday plans.
The aircraft has been sabotaged by Allura's dangerous stalker, leaving the women facing a frightening situation thousands of feet above the ground. With the possibility of a crash becoming increasingly real, Dina attempts to calm everyone down through a personal exercise. She asks each woman to share a regret, hoping that a moment of honesty might help them manage the frightening circumstances.
Carr's answer turns out to be one of the episode's most revealing moments. Rather than making another sarcastic comment or finding an opportunity to criticise Liberty, she admits that she genuinely respects her rival for having the courage to come out. More surprisingly, Carr reveals that she wishes she possessed the same confidence because she has experienced a subtle attraction towards women and has wondered what it might be like to explore that side of herself.
It is a surprisingly vulnerable admission from someone who usually appears determined never to let anyone see beyond her confident exterior. Carr does not offer a detailed explanation of her feelings, nor does she attach a specific label to her sexuality. Nevertheless, her confession provides the clearest indication yet that she could be questioning whether she is attracted to women.
The immediate danger eventually passes when Allura's skilled new bodyguard, Raul Ortiz, manages to prevent the plane disaster. Although the group survives, Carr's admission leaves an interesting impression. The women have witnessed a different side of her, and the experience appears to have softened some of the hostility that previously defined their relationships.
The change becomes particularly noticeable between Carr and Liberty. Following the flight, Carr approaches her rival to ask about her relationship with Jamie, only to discover that the romance has already ended.
Their conversation suggests that Carr is becoming more comfortable around Liberty, although it remains difficult to determine whether her curiosity is purely friendly or something more personal.
As Thanksgiving approaches, the two lawyers find themselves representing opposing sides in a couple's divorce case. Under normal circumstances, this would probably provide another opportunity for them to exchange insults and make life unnecessarily difficult for everyone involved. Instead, their usual hostility seems to have lost some of its intensity.
The firm's Thanksgiving dinner offers another small indication that their relationship might be changing. When everyone gathers at the office for the meal, Carr and Liberty share a noticeably more relaxed interaction. Their conversations even carry hints of flirtation, suggesting that the rivalry between them could be developing into something rather different.
However, All’s Fair has not officially confirmed Carr's sexuality. Her admission establishes that she has experienced attraction towards women and is curious about exploring those feelings, but it does not necessarily mean she identifies as bisexual, lesbian or queer. At this stage, the series leaves plenty of room for interpretation.
So, is Carr straight or queer in All’s Fair? Based on what she reveals in Season 2, she appears to be questioning her sexuality and exploring the possibility of being attracted to women. Her comments suggest potential bisexual curiosity, but there is no definitive label attached to her yet. Whether this eventually develops into a romantic relationship with Liberty is another question entirely.
Opinion: Carr and Liberty Could Become All’s Fair's Most Interesting Couple
Carr's storyline is arguably one of the more interesting developments in Season 2 because it gives a character known for her sharp remarks and competitive nature an opportunity to show some genuine vulnerability. Her confession does not suddenly change her personality, which is a good thing. She can still be difficult, sarcastic and occasionally exhausting, but viewers now have a better understanding of what might be happening beneath that confident exterior.
The possibility of a romance with Liberty is also worth exploring, particularly because their relationship already has plenty of tension. However, the writers should avoid rushing them into a relationship simply because Carr has admitted her curiosity about women. Sexuality deserves more than a convenient romantic twist, and Liberty should have room to develop beyond her previous relationship, too. A slow-burning romance could work brilliantly here, provided the series gives both women enough time to understand what they actually want.
For now, Carr's sexuality remains an open question, but her confession has certainly changed the way viewers might interpret her interactions with Liberty. Whether the two lawyers eventually become something more than professional rivals remains to be seen. Do you think Carr is genuinely interested in Liberty, or is their growing closeness simply the result of surviving a frightening experience together? Share your thoughts and predictions about where All’s Fair Season 2 could take their relationship next.