 |
| Brothers Season 1 Episode 4 Recap and Review. |
Apple TV’s Brothers turns Wyatt’s 16th birthday into a rather chaotic family affair in Episode 4, as Woody becomes increasingly obsessed with the mystery surrounding his father, Matthew’s political ambitions run into an awkward family secret, and a hunting trip ends with an actual deer becoming the only thing everyone can agree was definitely dead.
The episode opens with Ma Mac preparing a huge birthday cake for Wyatt, while Woody tries to revisit the revelation that he and Matthew may have a much more complicated connection than either brother wants to admit. Ma Mac dismisses the whole thing as something she said while drunk, but that explanation does little to settle Woody’s mind. If anything, it gives him another reason to keep digging.
Wyatt’s birthday celebrations take an unexpected turn when he opens Matthew’s present and discovers a hunting rifle. For Matthew, it is clearly intended as a meaningful gesture between father and son, but Woody is less than impressed. His views on hunting have already been made pretty clear, so watching Matthew encourage Wyatt to take up the sport is hardly going to win him any points.
Matthew, meanwhile, has bigger concerns beyond birthday presents. He meets Mrs Hillcrest-Barnes-Davies, an experienced campaign manager who has won nine consecutive elections in the region. She wastes almost no time dissecting Matthew’s political image, including taking a swipe at his wife Val for being, in her words and attitude, painfully dull.
Her assessment of Matthew is more interesting, though. She points out that he appears to have no obvious scandals or skeletons waiting to emerge. Matthew is convinced there is nothing for anyone to find, but the timing is unfortunate. The mystery surrounding the brothers is exactly the sort of family complication that could become a political headache if it ever gets out.
The next morning, Matthew and Wyatt head off on their hunting trip, only to discover that the outing has gained several unexpected passengers. Olive decides she wants to join them, while Kai comes along too. What Matthew imagined would be a quiet father-son bonding session is therefore becoming something closer to a family road trip with firearms, which sounds reassuringly sensible.
Woody has other business to deal with. He heads to a local bar looking for information about Ma Mac and his father, Clive Harrelson. Nobody seems particularly interested in helping, although the bartender recognises the Harrelson name. More importantly, after Woody leaves, the bartender makes a call and reports that he has just turned up.
That small detail becomes increasingly important as the episode progresses.
When Woody learns that the girls have joined the hunting trip, he decides he cannot simply stay out of it. He catches up with the group just as Wyatt is preparing to shoot a deer and promptly throws himself in front of the animal, stopping the shot.
It is an impressive display of Woody being Woody, but Matthew is understandably furious. His carefully planned opportunity to bond with Wyatt has been wrecked, while Woody believes Matthew has abandoned his own principles by taking the family hunting. There is also the small matter of Matthew apparently taking the girls along without properly considering what Woody thinks about it.
The brothers' argument continues inside the car, with neither showing much interest in letting the other have the final word. Then comes the episode's funniest piece of irony: they crash into a deer and kill it anyway.
So much for avoiding the taking of a life.
Back at the house, Matthew and Woody bring the dead deer home and each delivers a speech over the animal. It is an oddly solemn moment after the ridiculous chain of events that led them there, and Brothers clearly enjoys the absurdity of two men arguing passionately about hunting only to end up with a dead deer sitting between them.
But the episode soon moves away from the comedy and back towards Woody's investigation.
Woody receives a call from Creaky Joe, the bartender from earlier, and goes to meet him. Instead of getting the answers he wanted, Woody is hit over the back of the head with a bottle and tied up.
When he wakes, he finds himself staring up at two elderly men known as the Travis Brothers, who are holding him at gunpoint. Their problem is not actually with Woody himself. They claim his father, Clive, owed them $1,800, disappeared without paying and never returned.
Naturally, nobody has been keeping the original figure frozen in time. With interest added over the years, the debt has ballooned to $191,000.
Woody is hardly carrying that sort of money around, and his attempts to explain that he is not responsible for his father's debts do not appear to make much difference. Fortunately, Ma Mac arrives before things become even more serious and manages to get Woody out of the situation.
Afterwards, Woody thanks her for stepping in, but Ma Mac's warning is more concerning than comforting. By digging into Clive's past, Woody has disturbed something that was better left alone, and she makes it clear that he may have kicked over a hornet's nest.
That warning gives Episode 4 a stronger dramatic edge beneath all the family bickering and hunting mishaps. Woody started the episode trying to understand the truth about his family, but his search is now uncovering old debts, people who clearly remember his father and a past that seems considerably messier than Ma Mac initially suggested.
The episode also works because Matthew and Woody remain so fundamentally different. Matthew wants structure, control and a respectable public image, particularly with his political ambitions taking shape. Woody, on the other hand, keeps charging into situations without necessarily knowing what he is going to find. Put the two together and even a simple birthday or hunting trip has about as much chance of staying peaceful as a deer standing in front of a rifle.
My take on Episode 4 is that the Clive Harrelson mystery is finally starting to feel like the central thread rather than a side curiosity. The $191,000 debt is ridiculous enough to fit the show's humour, but it also raises a much more serious question about what Clive was involved in before disappearing. Ma Mac clearly knows more than she is saying, and her warning to Woody feels deliberately important.
I also liked how the hunting storyline mirrors the wider family conflict: everyone thinks they know what is right, then the situation immediately proves otherwise. Matthew's political storyline adds another layer because even a relatively small family secret could become awkward if it reaches the wrong people. And the deer incident is exactly the sort of darkly comic disaster Brothers does well. Episode 4 leaves Woody with more questions than answers, which is probably the point, but now there are real consequences attached to finding those answers.
By the end of Episode 4, Woody's curiosity has gone well beyond family gossip. Clive's past appears to have people willing to hurt Woody over it, while Matthew has his own reasons for wanting the family's secrets kept under control. With Ma Mac warning that things could escalate quickly, the next episode has plenty of unfinished business to deal with. What do you think Woody is going to uncover about Clive, and do you think Ma Mac has been hiding the biggest part of the story?