الصفحة الرئيسية
JKT48
KLP48

KLP48 Captain’s Shocking Performance Draws Comparisons with JKT48 Trainees

KLP48 captain faces criticism after a hesitant stage moment in Sepang, sparking comparisons with JKT48’s stricter performance standards spark debate.
Debate Erupts as KLP48 Captain’s Performance Draws Comparison with JKT48 Trainees
Fans Question KLP48’s Professional Standards After Viral Stage Moment (Photo: Yi Shyan/Twitter)

Kuala Lumpur–based AKB48 sister group, KLP48, is once again at the centre of online discussion after a recent stage performance at the GT Live Concerts Autobacs Super GT Malaysia 2025 in Sepang drew sharp reactions from fans and observers. The focus has landed on Yi Shyan, a member who has been active for over two years and currently holds the role of captain, following a moment during a group dance that many felt disrupted the overall flow of the performance.

A circulating video clip from the show highlights a noticeable pause by the leftmost performer, lasting close to ten seconds. 

While some viewers described it as a brief lapse, others saw it as a serious breakdown in stage awareness, especially given the scale of the event and Yi Shyan’s leadership position within the group. 

The moment quickly became a talking point across fan communities, with comparisons emerging almost instantly.

Much of the discussion contrasts KLP48’s performance with the widely praised stage presence of JKT48’s 12th Generation trainees, who delivered a smooth and energetic rendition of “Melon Juice” during the AKB48–JKT48 Sister Reunion in October 2025. 

Fans pointed out how the trainees maintained strong expressions and clean formations throughout, reinforcing the idea that consistency and recovery on stage are essential benchmarks within the 48 Group ecosystem.

This renewed criticism also arrives against the backdrop of earlier tensions between Malaysian and Indonesian fans. 

Some Malaysian supporters had previously accused JKT48 fans of undermining KLP48 during a December 2025 controversy involving exposed group chats. 

Ironically, others now note that the heightened attention may have contributed to KLP48’s recent visibility, including invitations to Motionime events and increased recognition online, even as questions about performance quality continue to surface.

Adding to the debate, another clip began circulating where critics shared footage of a KLP48 captain stumbling mid-performance (blanked), accompanied by casual Indonesian commentary suggesting that mistakes happen across all groups. 

However, many viewers argued that the key difference lies in how idols respond in real time. 

JKT48 is often credited with masking errors through strong expressions, quick recovery, and teamwork, something fans feel was missing in KLP48’s recent appearance.

Reactions among fans remain divided. 

Some speculate that Yi Shyan may have been unwell or dealing with physical strain, while others dismiss this explanation and emphasise the need for stricter evaluation. 

With KLP48 now having its own new theatre building and preparing for regular performances, supporters are increasingly vocal about the importance of meeting recognised 48 Group professional standards.

Many fans are calling for constructive evaluation rather than personal attacks, urging both members and management to treat this moment as a chance for growth. 

What do you think—was the criticism fair, or has the situation been blown out of proportion? 

#JKT48 #KLP48

إرسال تعليق