![]() |
| Mike Elder Now: Black Sheep Custom Cakes, Guinness World Records and Family Life. |
Mike Elder may have missed out on the winning title on Netflix’s Is It Cake? Halloween, but his talent for turning ordinary cake ingredients into extraordinary creations has continued to keep him busy. The Kansas-based cake artist has built a career around sculpted desserts, television competitions and ambitious artistic projects, including edible vehicles that earned him Guinness World Records. Away from the cameras, he runs Black Sheep Custom Cakes, raises three children as a single father and explores creative work far beyond the kitchen. In other words, losing a baking competition has hardly sent him back to measuring flour in peace.
Elder appeared in the second season of Is It Cake? Halloween, where he faced two other contestants in the opening episode. The challenge demanded sharp eyes and a steady hand, with bakers tasked with making cakes convincing enough to pass as everyday objects.
Spotting a spider-shaped cake among the display pieces helped Elder secure his place in the competition, but recognising a fake and creating one are two very different skills. One requires observation; the other requires an impressive amount of patience and, presumably, the ability to remain calm when a perfectly good cake starts looking like a building project gone wrong.
For his main challenge, Elder drew inspiration from a childhood Halloween memory involving a neighbour who used a chainsaw as part of his spooky decorations. He turned that recollection into a realistic chainsaw-shaped cake, combining maple rum cake with walnut maple buttercream. It was an unusual flavour pairing, but Halloween has never been a holiday particularly concerned with conventional decisions.
Getting the cake out of its mould proved to be the biggest headache. Once released, the creation looked better on one side than the other, prompting Elder to flip it before presenting it to the judges. It was a simple adjustment, but sometimes the difference between an impressive creation and an awkward reveal comes down to knowing which side deserves to face the audience.
His gamble paid off. Placed beside a real chainsaw, his cake successfully fooled the judges, leaving Elder delighted that they had failed to identify the edible imposter. The result secured his place in the final alongside fellow contestant Corinna Maguire. However, Maguire ultimately won the competition, with the judges considering flavour and taste alongside visual presentation. Elder had successfully delivered the trick, but the final decision proved that looking convincing is only half the battle. Even in a competition about fooling people, a delicious cake still needs to taste like one.
Away from Netflix, Elder continues to run Black Sheep Custom Cakes, his custom cake business based in Wellington, Missouri, serving the Kansas City area. His work focuses on wedding cakes, elaborate sculpted designs and creations that often resemble objects far removed from the usual birthday-cake territory.
Rather than treating cake decorating as a simple finishing touch, he approaches the craft as a form of sculpture, using edible materials to reproduce shapes, textures and details that can make people question whether they should reach for a knife or call a mechanic.
His portfolio includes hot rod cakes, zombie-themed designs and other intricate pieces that demonstrate his ability to work on a much larger scale than a standard celebration cake. His television experience includes appearances on Cake Wars and Halloween Wars, while he has also been billed as a three-time undefeated champion of TLC's Ultimate Cake Off. Desert Professional Magazine named him among North America's ten best cake designers, adding another distinction to a career built around making desserts that are almost too convincing to eat.
One of Elder's most unusual achievements came in November 2020, when he worked with nine assistants to construct two racecars made entirely from cake. The project earned two Guinness World Records for the longest distance travelled by an edible vehicle and the fastest edible vehicle. It is the sort of achievement that sounds ridiculous until you consider the engineering involved. Most people struggle to keep a sponge cake intact on the journey from the kitchen to the dining table, yet Elder helped create vehicles capable of moving under their own power. His work has earned him three Guinness World Records in total, alongside appearances on 16 television programmes and commissions delivered across three continents.
His clients have included some equally memorable projects. One notable commission was a four-foot-tall Beef Wellington cake created for the opening of Gordon Ramsay's Steak in North Kansas City. Elder has also said that celebrities including George Lucas and David Letterman have reportedly requested his cakes. Whether the occasion involves a restaurant opening, a famous client or an ambitious artistic challenge, his career demonstrates how a specialist skill can become a business with an identity far beyond its original niche.
In 2025, Elder teamed up with Cami SanRomani of Cami's Cake Co. to recreate Arrowhead Stadium for the Kansas City Chiefs' AFC playoff run. The project also included cake likenesses of Patrick Mahomes, KC Wolf and Andy Reid. Reproducing a stadium in cake form is an ambitious undertaking even before adding recognisable faces to the assignment. For a sports fan, it was a celebration of the team; for a cake artist, it was another opportunity to prove that edible creations can become much more than the centrepiece of a party.
Elder's creative interests also extend into murals, wood, clay and steel. He has painted murals in his hometown and Historic Northeast Kansas City, including a section of the area's well-known truck-eating bridge. These projects reveal a broader artistic interest that does not depend on buttercream or fondant. Cake may be his best-known medium, but his willingness to experiment with other materials suggests that the underlying attraction is the process of building something distinctive, whether it can be eaten afterwards or not.
He also supports Icing Smiles, a national nonprofit organisation that provides custom birthday cakes for critically ill children. The initiative gives professional cake artists an opportunity to use their skills to create special moments for families dealing with difficult circumstances. For Elder, this work offers a meaningful extension of his profession, showing how a highly specialised craft can bring joy beyond television competitions and commercial commissions.
Family life is another important part of Elder's story. He has spoken about being a single father to three children, describing parenthood as an experience that has taught him valuable lessons and given him plenty to appreciate. Creating memories with his children matters to him, and their trips together offer a chance to enjoy experiences outside his demanding professional life. Running a business while raising three children is no small undertaking, especially when the business involves intricate projects that can require hours of concentrated work. There are only so many hours in a day, and apparently some of them have to be reserved for both family time and making a cake that looks suspiciously like industrial equipment.
Elder has also been candid about the personal challenges of appearing on television. Reflecting on seeing himself on screen, he acknowledged that he has struggled with his weight over the years and described himself as a stress eater. He explained that difficult experiences had affected him and admitted feeling embarrassed about something that should otherwise have been a source of pride. His comments offered a more personal perspective on the experience of being filmed and judged, reminding viewers that appearing on television does not necessarily mean feeling comfortable with every aspect of how one is portrayed.
Beyond baking and family responsibilities, Elder is an animal lover with a particular fondness for turkeys. He has advocated for saving them during Thanksgiving rather than making them part of the traditional holiday meal. His affection for animals also extends to Ricky Bobby, his pet raccoon, who features in photographs and videos he shares. A raccoon is certainly an unconventional household companion, although anyone who has ever watched an animal ignore the rules of a carefully organised home might argue that the arrangement is not entirely surprising.
Elder also supports community activities, including costume parties and mural-painting projects that encourage people to get involved in local art. These interests reflect a side of his life that is less concerned with competition results and more focused on bringing people together. Between cake commissions, television appearances, parenting and community projects, he has built a varied career that gives him plenty to do even when there is no prize money waiting at the finish line.
My take is that Mike Elder's story is more interesting than a simple tale about a contestant who nearly won a Netflix competition. His chainsaw cake showed the technical skill needed to fool a panel of judges, but his work outside the show reveals the full range of his ambition. Building edible racecars, recreating a football stadium and producing sculpted wedding cakes all demand creativity, patience and a willingness to take on projects that could easily become expensive disasters.
His charitable work adds another dimension, while his openness about balancing parenthood and personal challenges makes his public image feel more grounded. Not every talented baker needs to win every competition to build a memorable career. Sometimes the more impressive achievement is creating work people remember long after the episode ends. And honestly, if someone can make a chainsaw out of cake, they deserve a little credit for making dessert considerably more intimidating than it needs to be.
For now, Elder remains associated with Black Sheep Custom Cakes, his sculpted creations and his wider artistic projects. His career shows that a television appearance can introduce an artist to new audiences without defining everything that follows. Did you think Mike Elder should have won Is It Cake? Halloween, or was Corinna Maguire the right choice? And which of his creations sounds more impressive to you: the realistic chainsaw, the edible racecars or the Arrowhead Stadium cake? Share your thoughts and let us know which project you would most like to see him attempt next.
